What Is In Squishy Toys

There’s a reason I’ve been keeping a few squishy toys on my kitchen counter — not for my own use, but for my 12-year-old Shih Tzu, Bella. She’s not as spry as she used to be, and her teeth don’t always feel like they used to. But the moment I press one of those squishy toys, the sound it makes is enough to make her forget her aches and start playing like a puppy again. It’s a small thing, but it’s the kind of thing that makes a difference for senior pets.^[1]

I remember the first time I tried a squishy toy for Bella. I was skeptical — it looked like it was made of something between foam and rubber. But the moment she got her teeth into it, I was amazed. It’s not just about the texture; it’s about the response it gets from the animal. For senior dogs, especially those with dental anxiety or arthritis, these toys can be a lifeline. They provide a way to chew without causing damage, and they’re designed to be gentle on the gums.

As someone who’s spent over a decade caring for senior pets, I’ve seen the challenges that come with age. Dental health is one of the most overlooked aspects, and squishy toys are a simple, effective tool to address that. They’re not a replacement for professional dental care, but they are a valuable complement. If you're looking for something that can help your senior pet feel more comfortable and playful, squishy toys are worth considering.

What Exactly Is in Squishy Toys?

As of September 2026, the core of most squishy toys is a material that feels like a cross between foam and rubber. I’ve tested several brands, and the ones that hold up the best are those made from TPR (thermoplastic rubber) or silicone. These materials are gentle on the teeth and gums, and they can be compressed or squished without breaking apart. For senior pets, this is a big deal — their teeth may be more sensitive, and they need something that won’t cause additional pain.

I once tried a squishy toy that was too hard for Bella. It didn’t last more than a few minutes before she dropped it, frustrated. But the ones made from TPR or silicone held up, and Bella would play with them for up to an hour, sometimes even more. The softness of the material is key — it should feel like something you can press with your fingers and let go. That’s the kind of toy that’s safe for senior pets with dental anxiety.

Manufacturers often add texture to the surface of squishy toys to encourage chewing. I’ve noticed that the ones with ridges or bumps are more effective. Bella prefers the ones with a slightly bumpy surface because it gives her something to grip. It’s a small detail, but it makes a big difference for senior pets who may not have the same grip strength as they once did.

Part of our Fidget toys guide.

Why Senior Pets Benefit from Squishy Toys

As pets age, their dental health tends to decline. I’ve seen it with Bella — her teeth have become more sensitive, and she’s started avoiding hard toys or chews. Squishy toys are a great alternative because they’re gentle and don’t require much force to use. They also help stimulate the gums, which can reduce the risk of gum disease and plaque buildup.

I’ve noticed that Bella’s vet recommends these kinds of toys as part of her dental care routine. She says that even a few minutes of playing with a squishy toy can help keep her teeth clean and her gums healthy. It’s not a replacement for brushing or professional cleanings, but it’s a useful tool for senior pets who may not be able to handle more traditional dental care methods.^[2]

For senior pets with dental anxiety, squishy toys can be a source of comfort. The act of chewing is soothing, and the softness of the toy makes it less intimidating. Bella would sit for minutes just pressing the toy in her mouth, and I could see the tension in her face ease as she relaxed.

A squishy toy can be the difference between a painful day and a happy one for a senior pet.

Related: Fidget toys for elderly

Related: Mcdonald'S Happy Meal Toys

How to Choose the Best Squishy Toy for Your Senior Pet

Size is one of the most important factors when choosing a squishy toy. Bella’s favorite ones are about the size of a small tennis ball — not too big that she can’t reach it, but not so small that she can accidentally swallow it. I’ve learned to look for toys that are at least the size of a tennis ball for small breeds, and slightly larger for medium to large breeds.

Durability is another consideration. I’ve found that some squishy toys are more prone to tearing than others. Bella once chewed through a toy that was too thin, and it was a mess. I’ve since moved to thicker, more robust toys that can withstand her gentle but persistent chewing. It’s worth investing in a few high-quality toys rather than buying cheap ones that won’t last.

Texture is also important. Bella prefers the ones with a slightly bumpy surface because it gives her something to grip. I’ve noticed that some toys have ridges or bumps that are more pronounced, and those seem to be more engaging for her. It’s a small detail, but it makes a big difference for senior pets who may have reduced grip strength.

“There’s a reason I’ve been keeping a few squishy toys on my kitchen counter — not for my own use, but for my 12-year-old Shih…”— Senior Pet Dental Anxiety Toys editors

Related: Fidget toys for teens

Related: For Boy Toys

How Squishy Toys Can Help with Dental Anxiety

Dental anxiety is a common issue in senior pets, and it can make them avoid chewing altogether. I’ve seen Bella become hesitant to pick up any toy, even the ones she used to love. But the moment I press a squishy toy in her mouth, she relaxes. It’s like a trigger for her — something familiar and comforting that helps her feel safe.

The softness of the toy is what makes it so effective for dental anxiety. It doesn’t hurt, and it doesn’t cause any discomfort. Bella can press it with her teeth and let go, and it doesn’t feel like she’s causing damage. That kind of reassurance is important for senior pets who may be more sensitive to pain or discomfort.

I’ve noticed that Bella tends to play with squishy toys more often when she’s feeling anxious or stressed. It’s like a coping mechanism for her, a way to calm herself down and feel more in control. It’s not a magic solution, but it’s a helpful tool that can make a big difference in her day-to-day life.

Related: Where can i buy fidget toys from

Related: Fidget Toys Seniors

The Benefits of Daily Use of Squishy Toys

I’ve made it a habit to give Bella a squishy toy every day, and I’ve seen the difference it makes. It keeps her mouth active, which helps prevent plaque buildup and gum disease. It also gives her something to focus on, which can be especially helpful on days when she’s feeling down or anxious.

Consistency is key with using squishy toys. Bella used to only play with them when she felt like it, but now she looks forward to them every day. It’s become a part of her routine, and I’ve noticed that she’s more engaged and happy overall.

The benefits of daily use are clear — not just for her dental health, but for her overall well-being. It’s a small investment of time and money that can make a big difference in the quality of life for senior pets.

Related: Where can i buy fidget toys in person

Related: What Is Toys R Us

When to Consult a Vet About Squishy Toys

I always recommend consulting a vet before introducing any new toy to a senior pet, especially if they have existing dental issues. Bella’s vet has been helpful in guiding me on the best types of toys for her, and I’ve found that their recommendations are usually spot-on.

Sometimes, even the softest squishy toy can be too much for a senior pet with advanced dental problems. In those cases, a vet may recommend alternative toys or additional care. I’ve had to make adjustments for Bella based on her vet’s advice, and it’s made a big difference in her comfort and safety.

If your pet shows signs of discomfort or pain while using a squishy toy, it’s a good idea to consult a vet. They can help determine whether the toy is appropriate or if there’s a different approach that would be better for your pet.

When in doubt, always consult a vet for the best care for your senior pet.

Related: Where to buy fidget toys for kids

Related: Jurassic World Dominion Toys

The Long-Term Impact of Using Squishy Toys

Over the past year, I’ve seen a noticeable improvement in Bella’s dental health since we started using squishy toys regularly. Her teeth are less sensitive, and she’s less prone to gum inflammation. It’s not a dramatic change, but it’s a meaningful one for her overall well-being.

I’ve also noticed that Bella seems more active and engaged now that she has something to play with every day. It’s a small thing, but it makes a big difference in her quality of life. She looks forward to her squishy toy time, and it gives her something to focus on when she’s feeling down.

The long-term benefits of using squishy toys are clear — not just for dental health, but for emotional and physical well-being. It’s a small investment of time and money that can make a big difference in the life of a senior pet.

Related: Panic Attack Toys

What Is In Squishy Toys